Impressive Pulled Pork Smoked On A Weber Smokey Mountain

WSM snow smokeThere are two major reasons to become a BBQ Pit Master; an endless supply of finely smoked meat, and showmanship (the ability to show off).  As Homer Simpson once said, “I am trying to impress people here Lisa. You don’t win friends with salad!”  If you are polishing your skills on the smoker, pulled pork is the drill for you.  It is a forgiving hunk of meat, it is an affordable way to feed the masses, and just the phrase pulled pork itself will make your friends and family drool and crave an invite to the feast.  For example, this year over Christmas break I posted pictures on Facebook of my smoker in the snow as I loaded up a brisket flat and my Mom commented “Does this mean pulled pork?”

Pulled pork is typically made from a cut of the swine called Boston Butt.  The Boston Butt is really pork shoulder and is located in the upper part of the front legs.  The ass-end of the pig is actually ham.  Pork butt, when smoked properly, is one of the best foods in the world.  When I talk about this cut of meat I primarily refer to it as pork shoulder, pork butt, or just simply put as butt.

When it comes to meat, I strive for consistency. When I select meat to smoke I don’t hunt around town for a sale price.  I do not buy my pork shoulder from the supermarket, I go to Costco.  The supermarket shoulders very so much in size from day to day.  My local Costco always has two packs of mostly trimmed boneless pork shoulder from Swift. I normally seek out a cryovac package that looks like it might contain two similar sized butts in the range of 7 pounds. Below is a picture of the last package of pork I purchased from Costco.  You can see I only paid $1.75 a pound and the sum of meat was about 14 pounds.  I  used to only cook one butt at a time, but a bit of extra prep and you get twice the bounty.  I love feeding my friends and family, and any extra pulled pork that does not get eaten can be frozen and reheated and enjoyed months later.  Pulled Pork Price Tag

Once you have taken your time selecting your butts and get home, open the package and rinse the meat off in a clean sink, and dry them well with paper towels.  During the wash I focus on feeling the butts for loose meat or excessive fat.  I consider any fat that is firm and larger than my pinky finger excessive and always try to remove it at this point.  Hopefully you took your time when selecting your package of pork and chose similar sized butts at the store but this is a good time to take note if your butts are extremely mismatched in size.  A large mismatch could result in your butts finishing at significantly different times.

Pulled Pork Rinse    Pulled Pork Trimming

After the wash and trim I like to inject my butts.  My most commonly used Injection is simple to make and easy to modify to your own personal taste preference.

Pulled Pork Injector

Simple Pork Injection = 2 Cups of apple juice + 1/4 Cup of apple cider vinegar + 2 Tbsp of your favorite rub.

Stir your injection mixture till the rub is fully dissolved.  Use a good injector, i like this affordable ($15) stainless steel  rig from BedBathBeyond. If you were planning on injecting a ton of meat I would definitely switch your injector selection to something more ergonomic like this “Made in the USA” Injector from amazon.  When injecting there is really only two things to focus on; getting flavorful liquid into you meat, and trying to not squirt juice all over your ceiling or kitchen cabinets.

When you are ready to inject, place your pork butts fat side down into some format of a tub.  Make your way around each butt injecting in grid-like pattern.  Insert the injector needle into your meat and begin to gently squeeze the injector as you slowly pull the needle out of the meat. If you squeeze too quickly or if you pull your needle too far out of the meat you will send a stream of juice across your kitchen onto your blinds / cabinets / ceiling.  If you clean it up now no one will notice or complain.  Take your time, inject the way that works best for you.  Don’t worry about getting every last drop inside your meat, just dump any extra on top.
Pulled Pork Injector

Pulled Pork Injecting1   Pulled Pork Injecting closeup

Now sprinkle a moderate layer of rub on top of your butts, cover, and and place in your refrigerator.  I like to let it linger for approximately 4 hours (you can go up to 24 hours).

Pulled Pork Ready for Fridge

Now that your ready to start smoking your pork butts, drain off any injection juices into your sink and liberally apply your favorite rub all over the butts.  For lack of a discrete volumetric description, go “semi crazy” here, no one ever complains to me that the bark was too tasty!  Keep it under 1/2 Cup per butt as an upper limit.

With the butt rubbed and ready to smoke, its time to go outside and light the fire.  I recommend using my fairly standard method of completely filling your WSM fire ring with unlit Kingsford Charcoal.  Then fully light about 20-25 briquets using a fire starter and carefully dump them into the center of your unlit briquettes. My smoking wood of choice is typically a blend of hickory and apple wood.  For pork butts and beef brisket I like to use a 50-50 blend of these two woods.  Gather yourself 2 nice tennis-ball-sized chunks of hickory and of apple wood and give them a bit of a char by setting them onto your lit coals for a few seconds.  Spin each chunk around and let all sides become charred a bit (takes about 3 minutes).  I now take these charred and smoking chunks and put them towards the outside of the fire ring where there are not many lit coals.  Now its time to assemble the smoker with all vents wide open and wait for the temperature to climb up into the 200 degree range.  Once it hits 200 degrees bring your butts out and place onto the smoker.  Begin to close vents as needed to lock down your temps in the 250 degree range.  With this configuration you will have a heat source that can comfortably produce 250 degrees for 12 or more hours with little-to-no adjustments.  This will also give you a wonderful layer of smoke flavor, a smoke ring that you can brag about, and confidence that your meat will not be too smokey.

Pulled Pork on Smoker

The angle that the above picture was shot does not show it but there are a few inches between each butt, allowing for complete air circulation around each butt.  When properly loaded we can estimate that 2 butts will take about the same amount of time as a single butt.Using a time table is always a bad idea, as it gives you false hope.  This time guideline will trick you into not letting the meat cook to the point where the meat is at its peak tenderness.  But because I can guess that you still want it, the common time table is 1.5-2 hours per pound @ smoking temperatures.  So by textbook guidelines a seven pound pork butt in a 250 degrees WSM will finish in about 10 to 14 hours. Go ahead and give yourself 2 hours per pound as a buffer as it is easier and preferred to hold your cooked meat warm than to rush a smoking session because your guests are hungry.

For this smoking session I put both of my butts directly onto the top cooking grate of the smoker and had the temp locked down at ~250 just before midnight.  I proceeded to go to bed with my alarm clock set for six am.  When I woke up the smoker was still chugging along near 250 degrees and I was happy.  The internal temperature of both pork butts was in the high 160’s.  Up until this point if you were sitting in a lawn chair next to the smoker staring at the reading on your meat probe it would be rising at a fairly uniform rate.  When the internal temperature of your pork butts get in the range of 150-170 it is common for the temp to flat line.  The temp will stay the same or toggle up and down a few degrees for up to a few hours.  This stuck range is what most folks refer to as “the plateau”.  Don’t worry this is good thing, this is when the magic happens.  When the meat is In this temperature range the connective tissues of the pork shoulder containing collagen melt and render out as gelatin.  This breaking down of connective tissues and rendering is essential to creating tender meat.  The beautiful thing about standard smoking temperatures (225-275) is that you will spend plenty of time in this range and end up with ultra tender tasty meat.  If you want to understand more about what is happening from a food / physics-sense read this article.

At this point in the smoke, the bark has fully set up and I place each butt into its own foil pan.  Using a trick my friend Glenn taught me, I pour a bottle of Stub’s Pork Marinade on top of each butt and tightly cover the pans in foil.  This marinade concoction adds a second layer of flavors (think zing) to the meat and the foil pan collects it and the natural juices that are dripping out of the meat towards the end of this cook. I have recently become a huge fan of Stubb’s and use the pork marinade on all of my butts and the beef marinade on all of my briskets.  Stubb’s marinades can be found online for about $5-6 a jar, but sometimes they can be found on sale at your local super market for about $3 each.  When they are on sale I recommend stocking up (PS I don’t like the Chicken Marinade).  After sealing up the butts in the marinade, I went back to sleep for a two hour nap.

I woke up waited for the internal temp to climb north of 180 before I began to check for tenderness.  Most of my pork butts finish in the 195-205 degree range.  When cooking multiple hunks of meat do not think that the smaller butt will always finish first, each piece of meat is unique and needs its own amount of time.  Cook it till it is done.  To check for tenderness slide a temp probe into the meat in a few places and note how much restriction there was.  If the meat is done the probe will slide into it with the same ease as a loaf of soft white bread.  I could describe a handful of things like room temp butter but you wont know what this feels like until you feel it for yourself.  Odds are you are going to get nervous and pull the meat off of the smoker because your scared that you are about to dry it out.  Don’t do it man, just walk away and check it again in 20 minutes.  Don’t worry about accidentally over cooking your meat.  When your cooking in the smoking range of temps (225-275) and checking every 20 minutes you will never go from almost tender to dry and nasty in a single interval.  Continue checking every 20 minutes in multiple places until your probe slides in super easy.

Pulled Pork is Done

Now that your pork has been smoked and is perfectly tender, remove it from the smoker.  Let your pork butts rest uncovered on the counter for around 15 minutes.  Be smart here the foil pan is stil hot, put pot holders or something below it to protect your counter tops.  You now have to chose one of two paths; pull or hold.   If you need to hold, because your waiting for guest to arrive, you should remove the butt from the foil pan and tightly wrap it in a few layers of aluminum foil.  Reserve the juices in the bottom of the foil pan for later, they can be used in a BBQ sauce. Take your foiled butts and wrap them in a towel and place into a cooler.  You can use any cooler you already own but I use a 24-can party stacker made in USA by Coleman. The stacker is cheap and an impressive form factor that fits most cooked butts / ribs / briskets. When your cooked meat is properly wrapped in foil, and the extra airspace in your cooler is filled by a towel, you can hold your meat at a safe temperature for hours.

If your meat was holding in a cooler, remove it and let is rest uncovered on on the counter to cool down. If your pork has been cooling down for 15 minutes it is now time to pull your pork. Get out your cutting board and carefully place your butt on it.  I like the simplicity and precision I get from two dinner forks.  Simply use the two forks and drag it across the meat, i.e pulling the pork.  I like to take my time while shredding the meat by also looking for and removing any undesirable non-meat bits.  Go ahead and process the entire pork shoulder and then mix up the center bits with the outer bark for a good blend of seasoning and texture. I get by just fine with my dinner forks but If I was given a set of Bear Paws I would use them.  Or if I was a complete bbq-bad-ass, I would use a machete

Pulled Pork Fork1  Pulled Pork Fork2

I also like to toss the shredded pork in the au-jus (natural juices) and remnants from the Stubb’s marinade from the foil pan.  If needed, add some very finely ground rub to your shredded pork mixture and toss some more. I have found when using the jus / Stubb’s combo, I have not needed any additional seasoning.  Never pre-sauce your pulled pork. Leave pre-saucing of pulled pork for the crock pot cookers.  Let your guests squirt a bit of BBQ sauce onto there pulled pork themselves.  I like to put out a variety of sauces and let people experiment.  Every one likes to experiment with BBQ sauces, and you start to see some trends forming on what sauces the majority of your guests enjoy most.  You only want to add BBQ sauce to accent the amazing meat you just smoked.  The bread you choose for pulled pork sandwiches is important.  I once got hearty thick heavy rolls that you could barely fit any pork inside and the end result tasted like dry bread with hint of pulled pork.  Your bread choice can be as simple as white wonder bread, or you could use my favorite  King’s Hawaiian Sweet Dinner Roll.  A few of the big name bread company’s are now making clones of the Hawaiian sweet rolls that can be used in place of King’s.  Take your bun, pile up your pulled pork, and enjoy every last bite!  If you really read every word of this post, wow, thanks for reading, best of luck in your smoking adventures!

This entry was posted in BBQ and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

25 Responses to Impressive Pulled Pork Smoked On A Weber Smokey Mountain

  1. Joe says:

    Well done. I love a good pulled pork and this recipe looks super simple. I love my WSM as well. Great cook!

  2. John Banu says:

    My guests will be eating between 2 and 4. Does midnight still work for a start time for two 8 pound butts?

  3. Jay says:

    John, a midnight start for an afternoon feast is what I feel to be perfect timing. I love having the smoked meat (non-ribs) wrapped up in a cooler waiting to be pulled when it is convenient. Way better than serving “not-quite-done” meats because your guests are impatient. Make sure your butts have a nice gap between them and are not touching as that could slow down your cook. Estimate 12 hours and if it finishes sooner wrap it up in extra layers of foil, wrap that with a towel, and stuff it in a Coleman party stacker cooler or another cooler you own. The biggest key is to fill up the empty space with towels, use multiple if needed.Just this past weekend I cooked two 8 lb butts and they took a total of 11 hours. I stored them for around 4 hours in my stacker, and they were perfect pulling temp when I served them.

  4. John Banu says:


    One more thing. Can I do the two butts on the two layers instead of both on top? I was thinking of throwing some chicken parts on the top grill around 11 AM. Last week I did some baby backs and put the chicken parts on the lower grill. My timing was off though. I know I should have added them later than the ribs because I had to take them off before the ribs were done. They came out delicious except they tasted like the rub on the ribs! I guess the juices from the ribs dripped down on them. So my plan this week is to let the butts cook and put the chicken on the top around the top butt at around 11. I’ll get the butts off around noon (approx) and let the chicken finish while the butts are in the cooler. Does that sound like a plan?

  5. John Banu says:

    Pork was a hit! Thanks Jay! Only hiccup was that I tried to put some chicken pieces on the smoker when the pork was at about 180. Packed them too tight and lost heat. Once I realized it I took the chicken off, finished the butts and packed them in the cooler, then put the chicken back on. We ate about an hour later than planned but everything was delicious! I had guests that went back for seconds and thirds of the pork. Thanks for the guidance. Can’t wait to do it again!

  6. Gil Rohde says:

    Jay, looks good! I have a few questions. I have the 18″ WSM and have smoked several pork butts. My method is very close to yours with a few differences. You didn’t mention the water pan. Do you use water or smoke with a dry pan? Looks like foiled and dry in one of your photos – I have always used water. I also haven’t injected before, but I just got one so am going to try this weekend. Also I usually wrap the butt in foil with some apple juice rather than the pan/marinade when it hits the plateau. My biggest problem is that I never get much of a smoke ring like the really nice looking one you have and more importantly I don’t feel there is enough smoke flavor even though I use plenty of wood chunks.

  7. Jay says:


    I typically do run my WSM foiled and dry, although I recommend those starting off to use water in the pan as a helper to learn vent settings and how they change the temps. Your method of foil and juice will work well too. Injecting is a part of my process and I enjoy the thought that it adds additional flavors to the final product. I think that I like wrapping butts directly better than using the foil pan, but on brisket flats I do like the pan. What kind of wood chunks are you using as in source, size, weight, species? Cheers and good luck

  8. Jeff says:


    Thanks for the instructions. One question: when you transfer to the foil pans do you have enough room to place them both on the top rack or do you use the lower rack? I barely have the room for one foil pan on my top rack.

    Thanks again.

  9. Jay says:


    I run the 22.5″ WSM and can fit two easily on the top rack. I think when i was using the 18.5″ WSM I would bend the foil pans to wedge them in or simply use two layers of aluminum foil. I prefer to not use multiple racks for simplicity sake.

  10. Eric says:

    FYI, It seems that the stall is increased evaporation from the surface. Rendering of fat and collagen happens earlier and continuously. I don’t remember where is the simulation or study that corroborated but it was a very good match the real-world temperature performance.

    So foiling before stall, substantially slows the evaporation which shortens its effect.

  11. Patrick Battaglio says:

    Jay: tried my new WSM out for a first real cook guests were coming at 6:00 and thought it would be ready by then; but got caught in the plateau time and could not get it to rise in temperature. So i now have a near cooked pork shouulder that finished at 250 degrees and its sitting in the fridge for tomorrow. What can i do to continue in cooking in the oven to finish it?

  12. Mike says:

    Excellent write-up Jay and thanks! I have had my WSM for about 5 years and have experimented quite a bit with variants of temp., foil/no foil, water/no water, pan/no pan, woods, fat cap up/down, rubs vs salt and pepper, etc. In the end, it’s all about “personal preference” and what makes you feel good or happy! What I have settled on is: 1) cook temp in the range of 220 – 250 or so, 2) no foil, 3) no water pan, 4) 50/50 hickory/oak (do not use too much – really just want a hint of smoked flavor), 5) use moderate sprinkling of course sea salt and course ground black pepper on butts 6) wrap in foil and let render once pulled from pit (195 – 205 internal temp) sitting in cooler w/towel for anywhere from 30 minutes – 3 hours depending on circumstances. I have found no difference in the fat cap on top or bottom – top however would seem to provide more baste. For my “personal taste”, the key is that the fat drips onto the burning coals producing a BBQ pit flavor (I do this for chickens as well with great results – crispy skin). The use of 50/50 hickory/oak is what many of the best BBQ establishments in Lexington, NC use – try it! By not foiling, the butt has a better consistency (not mushy in my opinion), and has a brown crust that is formed by the outer layer of fat that has cooked down to a flavorful crust. My “personal” opinion is that too much rub, etc. inhibits the penetration of natural smoke flavor produced by the wood and juices cooking on the coals. This method is EASY, produces Lexington style “Q” and is inexpensive (no fancy rubs or marinades or soaking overnight). I’ve never believed in making anything more complicated that it needs to be… ENJOY!!!

  13. Jay says:

    Great comments Mike ,thanks for reading, and adding in about your methods.

  14. Dan Schmidlkofer says:

    Enjoyed your site! Great recipe for the butts. I was doing most of what you do, and I added the injection. Good stuff! Thanks for sharing…

  15. Jay says:

    Good work Dan, glad to share, sounds like you prob have a loyal group of friends and family hanging around your bbq pit.

  16. Larry Bessicks says:

    very good did not have stubbs pork marinade could not find not amazon not even I went to Mars store one day and found 5 bottles I bought them all I told them to reorder and they said it has been discontinue. thats why you can find it. any other pork marinades close to the same first time smoker.

  17. Todd says:

    Hi Jay,
    Awesome post. I am smoking approximately 60 lbs of pork shoulder for a wedding. I will not have time to do it the day of the wedding. What is your opinion of reheating the pulled pork the day of the wedding. I was thinking I could pull it ahead and reheat the meat in zip lock bags in a water bath,and then transfer to preheated crock pots for serving. What do you think? Do you have a different way that you think is a better way? Thanks for your input.

  18. Jay says:

    Todd your idea is solid and will work fine, just make sure that you follow proper food safety procedure. Biggest challenge for you on your pre-cooked pulled pork is going to be chilling it quickly. People whom cater and do these things for a living will have shallow pans and flash freezers. For us backyard pit-masters, use cookie sheets and your freezer and pull / chill one butt at a time. Then seal and refrigerate till your event, rinse and repeat. You may have just inspired me to write a food safety article, and write up for how to safely chill / store / re-heat and serve.

    Storing Leftovers
    One of the most common causes of foodborne illness is improper cooling of cooked foods. Bacteria can be reintroduced to food after it is safely cooked. For this reason leftovers must be put in shallow containers for quick cooling and refrigerated at 40 °F or below within two hours.

    Foods should be reheated thoroughly to an internal temperature of 165 °F or until hot and steaming. In the microwave oven, cover food and rotate so it heats evenly.


  19. Jay says:

    Larry, that is unfortunate, I will check for it around my neck of the woods and follow up with you. For now substitute something on the thinner side of sauces that you like the taste of, perhaps a jar of bone sucking sauce?

  20. PAUL NORFOLK says:

    Hi Jay,
    my new WSM arrives just in time for Easter 2016. I intend to go straight in and try and smoke a pork shoulder for my family over that weekend as it’s one of the first reasons I considered buying the smoker. I love good pulled pork and your method above appears to be easy to follow. However I find the more I read on what people prefer when cooking i.e water/no water, foil/no foil just causes me some confusion.
    I intend to follow your method and living in London have had to splash some cash by ordering an imported bottle of the pork marinade you recommend! But I feel it’s worth it.
    One question and please excuse me if it’s already been answered. I’m taking it that I need to put the pork in the pre-heated smoker, cook it at around 250 for around 6 hours (I appreciate this depends on the weight of the meat) and then foil it and continue to cook. Is that basically correct in the guidance I seek?

    I’m hoping this Easter treat will be the start of a long and enjoyable amount of years spent providing excellent slow cooked meat to my family and friends. My wife is Greek Cypriot and they use the rotisserie style of bbq to cook their lamb and pork. She thinks I’m crazy but I intend to prove her wrong!
    Thanks again for the excellent article on here.
    Paul (London, England)

  21. PAUL NORFOLK says:

    Did my first ever smoke this weekend. A huge piece of pork butt. Lit the WSM up at midnight and an hour later the temp was a steady 125. Woke up 6am to check the meat and the thing had gone out. Some charcoal still black at the edges.
    I relit the WSM with fresh coals but once again they only lasted for approx 4 hours before the temp started to dip (I had been keeping an eye on the vents to ensure the temp was steady).
    In the end I decided to take the pork out and stick it in the over as the meat coast me a fortune and I didn’t want it ruined by inconsistent heat.

    The strange thing is after removing the pork I took off the lid and used the remaining dying coals to cook some kebabs and with the WSM lid off the coals went back to red hot once again. So my first thoughts that the Big K coals were not good quality is clearly wrong. I just cannot think why and of course I’m really disappointed.

    Does anyone have any suggestions. This new venture was exciting for me but I feel very flat this morning.


  22. Alex says:

    Just got my smokey mountain and 2 butts. This article just got me so fired up to smoke these bad boys. Thanks for writing!

  23. PAUL NORFOLK says:

    Hi Jay/all,
    I’m not sure if this site is still taking questions but here goes.

    After last years early attempts at pulled pork I managed to pretty much get it right on the several occasions I cooked a pork butt through the year. My friends and family were impressed which is always a bonus. But the one issue I continually had was trying to find a suitable bread/roll product here in the UK .
    I’ve Googled the King’s Hawaiian Sweet Dinner Roll but of course you can’t buy them in the UK. I wondered if there was any suggestions you guys could give as to something suitable available here in the UK? I can of course carry on experimenting but it’s such a shame to spoil such excellent meat with bad rolls!
    Any suggestions much appreciated.


  24. Nick says:

    Hi Jay, hi all,

    first of all: Thanks alot for the great instructions Jay! They really helped me alot on my first butts. I’ve read alot about smoking butts, but this is one of the best instructions I’ve read. Not too complex, yet simple

    @Paul: I live in Germany and have the same problem finding a nice bread/roll that goes nicely with pulled pork. We don’t have the nice mushy bread as in the states. So what do Ido, when I can’t find anything that fits?
    Make it myself! And boy… that’s the best decision I’ve made regarding my pulled pork. With a mixer for dough it isn’t really that much work. Besides… it’ll give you something to do when not on the grill. 😉

    Just go the extra mile and you’ll find yourself in pulled pork heaven. It’s totally worth it! Just find the recipe that fits your taste the best.

  25. Nick says:

    Hi Jay, hi all,

    first of all: Thanks alot for the great instructions Jay! They really helped me alot on my first butts. I’ve read alot about smoking butts, but this is one of the best instructions I’ve read. Simple enough to understand, detailed enough so everthing important is said. Alot of instructions/Articles are apparently written by scientist, others by a 5 year old. This one’s just perfect. Thanks alot!

    @Paul: I live in Germany and have the same problem finding a nice bread/roll that goes nicely with pulled pork. We don’t have the nice mushy bread as in the states. So what do I do, when I can’t find anything that fits?
    Make it myself! And boy… that’s the best decision I’ve made regarding my pulled pork. With a mixer for dough it isn’t really that much work. Mix the ingredients, let sit for 45 minutes, form rolls add sesame seeds (optional) and shove them in the oven. Besides… it’ll give you something to do when not on the grill. 😉

    Just go the extra mile and you’ll find yourself in pulled pork heaven. It’s totally worth it! Just find the recipe that fits your taste the best.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *